EroticReverie

*commissioned*

Nicolette Rhoades - Paxton

Everyone knows how me and my wife got pregnant. Well. They know what they need to. My wife Claudia and I used her brothers sperm to get me pregnant. We didn't trust getting a donor, and didn't trust someone else to carry our child, nor, did we want them to. I had wanted the experience of carrying the child myself. Since Claudia had no desire to carry, when we decided we'd wanted another child, we asked her brother again to be the donor. 

The one thing is , that nobody knows the specifics of how I came to get pregnant. We let them all believe it was through artificial insemination. The only people knowing the truth we me, my wife, and her brother Daniel. When we'd brought up the idea of natural conception to him, he admittedly was a bit freaked out. And yes, it was definitely an odd option. But, it was the cheapest option. why pay a doctor to do something that was pretty easy do to on our own? 

Plus me and Claudia were both what they call "Gold Star Lesbians". Lesbians who had never been intimate with a guy ever. So we were both comfortable in knowing that there was no underlying interest between me and Daniel having sex. It was very clinical actually, and most times, very short, with me propped with my legs open, just waiting for him to be ready to finish, then he'd finish inside of me. It took us 6 months to make it happen the first time. 

That was about four years ago. 

Now me and Claudia, have a three year old boy and as of a four to five months ago we'd been wanting to try for our second. Wanting to keep things simple, we asked Daniel if he would participate once again. 

Daniel was on board and told us he'd just have to discuss things with Beth, his current fiance. Beth knew exactly how Daniel had donated his sperm last time. Beth was also really fond of Nikolai our three year old boy. Her and Daniel helped out and baby sat for us numerous times over the past year and half that they've been together.  Daniel was a big part of our lives, more so than he was before I'd had his baby. Well, mine and Claudia's baby. 

That was thing, one thing I never spoke of with anyone, not even my partner. With Daniel being so much more involved in our lives now, it was hard for me not see him as more than just being the biological father. He'd acted like Nikolai's parent just as much as me and Claudia did. 

A week after us mentioning to him that we wanted him to try to help us conceive again, he'd let us know that Beth was not on board currently, but that he'd talk to her. We assured him not to worry, and not to push it. But that was thing about Daniel , he'd loved his sister so much, their family always so close, and he loved little Nikolai even more, wanting him to have a little sister or brother. So he told us that he was doing it whether or not Beth agreed, that they just had their own personal issues happening, unrelated to what we were asking of him. 

A month later, they'd broken off their engagement and Beth moved out. We consoled Daniel, but he hadn't really needed it. He insisted that Beth was selfish and that he wouldn't want to marry someone who couldn't understand the gift he was giving to us. 

When we were sure that Daniel was a hundred percent positive he wanted to be involved again, we made a "date" for the days I would be most fertile. 

---

On my first cycle, Daniel had come over, and in our guestroom, while Claudia was in the other room with out baby, Daniel had done it just like we'd done last time he'd gotten be pregnant.. Claudia never had given any rules to us, and I'd assured her that it was all very respectful, and clinical and wasn't emotional or enthralling for me in any way. But the second night of my ovulation when Daniel was over, I'd been extremely horny. My hormones had felt like they were higher than they'd ever been and when I told Daniel he didn't have to masturbate, that he could just do it normally, he'd seemed surprised, even though there were a few times the last he got me pregnant, that he'd actually had sex with me. Which was towards the end. 

"I just mean...last time....it seemed to work once we actually...you know." I say and he nods, walking over to the bed. 

"How would you like me to do it?" he asks, his hand on his cock , stroking it. 

His eyes hold no lust, and he's not jerking himself off to tease, or turn me on, but just to keep himself hard for the "project" that we jokingly started to call it. 

"Umm, I don't know." I shrug, remembering back to when we'd done it together before. How he'd taken be from behind, both of us agreeing it was the less intimate way, as we wouldnt be facing each other. 

"We can just start like this." he says with a shrug and I nod as I sit on the edge of the bed in my knee length summer dress. 

"Let me just.." I say and stand and slip my hands up my dress and pull down my panties. 

He nods as I sit back down on the bed. 

"Do you have lube?" he asks and I chew my lip. 

"Yes, but I...I'm fine right now.." I say my cheeks heating. I see his hand pause on his cock. 

"I just....my hormones have been crazy so...I'm already...well" I say and his eyebrows jump for a second and he nods. 

"Sure ok" he says and I have no idea why for some reason it feels more awkward than it did the first time we tried getting pregnant. Maybe it was because Daniel was a much bigger part of my life now, I saw him more, bonded with him more. Or maybe it was because even though it was my wife who I was supposed to see as the other parent to out son, it was actually Daniel that I'd pictured whenever I thought about who Nikolai's parents were. I'd never admit it to my wife, because I love her, and I'm not a monster and I know it would break her heart to hear me say that. She's a great mother, and a great wife, but I still couldnt help but think sometimes that Nikolai was mine...and Daniel's.  We were raising Nikolai to call him uncle Daniel, but in my head, he was Nikolai's father. Just as much as me and Claudia were his mothers. 

"You want to lay back?" Daniel asks moving forward and I nod and lean back and then lay back slowly, feeling my hair spill over the bed beneath my head. 

Daniel gives a polite smile and nods. 

"Maybe you should...here" he says he gently lifts my legs, and braces me under my knees gently with his hands and I watch him inhale and then exhale as he looks down between my legs. 

"do you want me to just put it in, or should i..um" he asks, trailing off. 

"Should you what?" I ask, feeling really awkward legs in the air, spread open with my ass at the end of the bed, bare pussy out for him. 

"No , just...sorry...it's weird right? Or is it just me? How did we do this last time so effortlessly?" he chuckles slight and it makes me laugh.

"I thought it was just me, but yeah...it's somehow more...awkward this time?" I say and he smiles and nods. 

"Okay, well as long as we're on the same page. We can work on it together." he says and I take a deep breath and nod. 

"It's just so weird, to just...I mean I know last time it was very , get in, make the drop, and get out." he says, and I laugh. 

"Yeah" I say and he smiles. 

"Do whatever you think." I say with a little shrug. "As long as you make the drop" I joke. both of us laughing and he nods. 

He clears his throat and looks down between my legs, and I watch his face as he grabs his cock. 

I gasp when I feel his cock push over me, not in me, but sliding between my lips, pushing the head of his cock over my clit and back down, he looks up at me. 

"That ok? If I just like...do this for a minute?" he asks. I nod silently. 

"Ok" he says and looks back down. My breath shakes as I inhale when I see him lick his lips as he looks back down and slides his cock again, back and forth over my wetness. 

He lets out a somewhat loud exhale. 

"fuck" he mutters. 

My eyes go wide. He looks up and then looks away bashfully. 

"Sorry, just...I didnt meant to say that." he says and before I can tell him it's fine , his cock starts to fill me. 

I gasp and feel him nudge against me until my pussy draws him in. 

I let out a moan and arch my back. 

I watch his jaw clench as he looks down, watching himself slide into me. 

I grab the blanket underneath me with my fists as I feel him connect his his hips to me, then draw back slowly. 

I exhale and close my eyes. I bite my lip and try to keep quiet, not wanting to show too much enjoyment. But...it's sex. It feels good. 

His thrusts are slow and gentle, and just...perfect. 

I moan slightly as I arch my back, my head going back as he leans forward, I feel him brace his hands on either side of me. 

I feel my mouth part, breathing, panting quietly as my wife's brother slides his cock in and out of me effortlessly. I can't remember the last time I was this wet. I tell myself it's just the hormones, just my libido being crazy, but truth be told, part of me couldn't wait for tonight. After having him inside me last night, even if just for a few moments while he'd deposited his cum inside of me. I'd craved it since last night. 

Claudia did well in the bedroom , fucking fantastic actually. The girl made me call her name and God's more times that I could count. Whether her mouth, her fingers, or her strap on, the woman had an incredible way of owning my body, of making it bend to her, making it cum for her. But this....with Daniel was different. Not better per se, but amazing in it's own way. I know I shouldn't be enjoying it, but again...it was sex...it was supposed to feel good. And god, did it ever feel good. 

"You ok?" Daniel breathed quietly, slowing inside me and I let my back relax, my head no longer digging into the bed as I looked back at him. His face was over mine now, watching me, his eyes on me.

Daniel never looked at me this way.

I felt my cunt clench his cock in response to whatever it was there I saw in his eyes and he inhaled. 

"I'm ok" I nodded.

"alright" he said and for the first time. I touched him. 

I lifted my hands to his bare chest as he hovered over me and he let out a slight groan. 

"It's okay to make noise Daniel." I tell him. 

I lick my lips and watch his eyes go to my mouth. 

"If it feels good, it's okay to make noise." I tell him. 

He lets out a brief laugh. "IF?" 

He curses under his breath. 

"It definitely...feels good Nic" he says. "Better than good." he says and my breath hitches. 

"it does?" I ask. 

"Does it not feel good for you?" he asks his brows lowering slightly. 

I bite my lips togther. 

"It feels wrong to say it does, doesnt it?" he asks. 

I nod. 

"Can I be honest Nic?" he asks. 

I nod as he gives me slow thrusts. 

"You feel....fucking fantastic." he lets out a slight groan. 

I let out a slight whimper as I bite my lip as he picks up his pace and my mouth parts again as I lay there, my hands slipping up his chest. 

"I know it's fucked up to say when we're just doing this to , you know...but...fuck...I'd be a fucking liar if I said I didnt enjoy being inside of you." he says and I let out a breath. 

"Daniel..." I say his name and before I can say another word, his mouth is on mine. 

I let out a tiny cry into his mouth as his cock thrusts harder once his mouth is on mine. 

"If we're going to do this Nic, there's no reason we shouldn't enjoy it." he says and I wrap my legs around him and my hands go to his back pulling him into me as he fucks me faster, the bed started to squeak. 

I feel guilty, wondering if Claudia can hear it, but most likely cant over watching the cartoons with Nikolai in the living room. 

"Tell me how it feels Nic" he groans against my mouth. 

I kiss him hard, my tongue parting his mouth and I kiss him with a passion I only reserve for Claudia. But he's Daniel, and in that moment, I let myself pretend that Claudia isn't in the other room, that it's me and Daniel....and Nikolai. That it's just us, that I'm the mother, he's the father, and it's just us three. 

"It feels so good" I pant and he groans into my mouth . 

"fuck Nic, mmmm" he growls and pushes up. 

"I love that I get to put another baby in you" he groans. 

My eyes widening slightly and my cunt clenching around him. 

"Mmmmm" he groans and looks down at his cock fucking me. 

"You're so gorgeous Nic" he says, reaching down, and his thumb rubs my clit. 

"jesus!" I gasp and my back arches. 

Daniel has never played with my clit before tonight, it was never about our pleasure before. It was about strictly, making a baby.  but why shouldnt our pleasure be involved? 

"yeah? That good?" he asks and I curse under my breath and look at him, nodding frantically. 

He smiles. 

"Is it wrong , that I was ready to cum as soon as I was inside you, but held off, cause I wanted to keep going? Wanted to feel you on my cock?" he asks and I let out a cry at his admission and he groans. 

"Dan" I pant as his thumb rubs me closer and closer. 

"I want to give you a baby Nic...." he groans and I moan. "But I also want to give orgasms while I do it." 

"oh fuck!" I curse quietly and my hands move all over, first clutching the bed covers , then I grab my tits through my dress and then one hand goes into my hair as I lift my head and look down to him fucking me. 

"oh god" I whine and my head falls back. 

"yesss" I hiss through my teeth, fighting my screams, as my toes curl, as my body pulses with an orgasm so intense as I cum on on Daniel's cock for the very first time. 

But not the last.