EroticReverie

*commissioned*

Daniel Paxton (a few days later)

We've been sneaking around behind my sister Claudia's backs for months now. The guilt eating away at me, making me want to stop the entire thing. But I kept telling myself it was fine, that Nicolette would eventually fall pregnant, and then we'd have no way of justifying what it was that we kept doing. 

Beth had made an attempt to rekindle things a few times, saying she'd wanted to work on things with me. I'd turned her down. I couldn't with good conscience try to work things out, when she had been right. When I wasn't just trying to impregnate my sisters wife, I was fucking her. Making love to her. I was enjoying every second with Nicolette more than I should have been. 

She'd come to me crying, we'd talk about returning to just having sex on her ovulating days, and then we'd end up fucking hard and crazed, the conversation ending up moot, because we'd have our mouths and hands all over one another. 

The guilt would be at it's worst when it was just me, Nicolette and Nikolai around. Whenever Claudia was busy, and it was just us....it felt right. It felt like Nikolai was really mine, and that we weren't in a decided arrangement. 

We acted like we were the married ones now, when Claudia wasn't around. I'd find ways to touch her, to stroke her hair when around Nikolai, innocent touches, that wouldnt be able to be confusing for a three year old. Just his "Uncle" being gentle and kind to his mother. 

Right now sitting next to Nicolette at the dinner table, I wanted to reach out and hold her hand, to rub my thumb over the top of her hand and tell her I'd missed her. But that was something that a husband did, not something a "Sperm donor" did to his sister's wife while sitting across from said sister. So I kept my hands to myself , eating the chicken dinner that Nicolette had made.

Nikolai sat beside me in a booster seat in his chair, and I pointed to his green beans telling him to eat a few more. All of us smiling when he grabbed the green beans in his fingers and shoved a mess of them into his mouth. 

"Not so much. Small bites." Nicolette said to him, prompting Nikolai to let some fall from his mouth back to the plate. 

"And use your fork please" Nicolette reminded him. 

--

After dinner Claudia took Nikolai upstairs for a bath and to put him to bed, while I stayed downstairs with Nicolette. 

I'd helped her clear the table and clean, and put the dishes in the dishwasher. Once the dishwasher was loaded and on, I grabbed Nicolette, spinning her, watching her eyes go wide for a moment , but then a smile coming to her lips as I lifted my hands to her face and leaned down to kiss her. 

She raised her hands to my forearms, holding onto them as she tilted her chin upward, making it easier for me to kiss her. 

"I missed you so much" I whisper as my hands fall from her face, to her waist and her hands go to my shoulders, then her arms wrapping around my neck. 

"I missed you too" she says quietly as I pull up her dress, letting my hand go right into her panties, making her gasp as I take her lower lip between my teeth. 

"Daniel" she pants quietly as my fingers find her clit and start to rub. She gasps as I let go of her lip, her head going back, and my mouth claims her neck, kissing it, licking it, biting it gently. 

"I want you, right now" I murmur against her neck near her ear.

"I NEED you right now" I groan and slide two fingers up into her as she parts her legs slightly. 

"Oh god Dan" she whispers , holding make little sounds of pleasure as I pump my fingers in and out of her. 

"This is so bad" she whispers. 

"I can't help it Nic..." I answer and fuck her cunt faster with my fingers, the mother of my child...soaking my fingers in the middle of the kitchen, with her wife, my sister, upstairs tending to the child we all share. 

"I want to taste you Nic" I groan and she gasps as my hand whips out of her panties, both hands grabbing her hips as I lift her swiftly onto the counter.

I grin when she protests, because as she protests, she lifts and spreads her legs as I reach between her legs tugging her panties to the side and then placing my face between her legs. 

"Jesus" she moans quietly, leaning back, bracing her hands on the edge of the counter , head against the cabinet , back arching, as I suck her clit and slide my two fingers back into her. 

I pump them , curling them, sucking her clit, and flicking it wildly as I groan into her pussy.

I groan because, she tastes so damn good, and groan also because I hate myself for how much I love eating my sisters wifes pussy. 

"Dan" she moans and I groan, standing up, and she reaches down for my bet, quickly releasing my cock and I groan as it springs free and I grab it angling it into her. 

"Shit" she whispers as I fill her, her legs flying around me along with her arms. 

We fuck quietly, only the slight little squeaks of her trying to silence her moans. 

"Harder" she whispers. "Fuck me harder" she bites my ear lobe and then my neck, her hands gripping at the back of my head in my hair, our eyes locked as I fuck her faster on the counter. 

"Yes" she grits her teeth. "fuck yes" 

Nicolette Rhoades

You'd think after crying almost daily at how much of a betrayal it is to fuck my wifes brother the way I do, that I'd stop. But I can't seem to stop myself once in his presence. 

Daniel was an amazing lover. Sex with him was exciting, and dirty, and then other times, romantic and loving and so fucking sweet. 

As much as I try to remind myself that Claudia is my wife, and SHE is Nikolais other main parent, it's been harder and harder to wrap my mind around, when I've become so close to Daniel, in ways beyond the way we've been physically. 

His cock is slick inside me, moving in and out with such each, like he's made a home inside me, his cock belonging there. With each stroke he proves it to me, by making it nearly impossible not to scream at the top of my lungs. 

I can hear Claudia upstairs, taking Nikolai from his bath and reach down and grab Daniel's ass and pull him into me. 

"Cum inside me" I whisper in his ear. 

"I want it Dan" I whimper. 

I squeal slightly, then shut myself up by biting my lips together as Daniel's hips slam into me and he pulls me off the counter, holding me up as he lifts me up and down on his cock as he fucks me. 

"Oh, fuck" I pant, my head going back as my body is jostled in his hold with each thrust. 

"Put a baby in me Dan" I moan, listening to him grunt as I lift my head and look back at him and nod. 

"Do it Dan...get me pregnant" I moan and he groans ass quietly as he can, jerking his release , his hands on my ass, holding me hard and then groans.

Seconds later, he's setting me down gently on my feet, and sliding out of me, then pushing my panties back to the side and straightening my dress. 

I smile as he pants, pulling his pants closed as I lick my lips. 

---

I tell Claudia, we're going to go for a round of the project and she laughs slightly and nods , still sitting in Nikolai's bed with him reading him a bedtime story. 

I go to the guest room we've given Daniel for the nights he's here. 

I'm stripped of my clothes slowly, by his gentle hands, his mouth finding new flesh as he bares my skin. Kissing my shoulders, my breasts, my stomach, following the falling fabric of my dress and then letting it pool at my feet, as he removes my panties once more and then stands. 

i do the same to him, taking my time, letting my hands push over his chest and down his arms, and then around to his back, pulling my bare chest to his after I've removed his pants and briefs. 

I shiver when his hand sweeps my hair off my shoulder and he kisses it, across it and over my collar bone then up along my neck, his hands slipping up and down my back, his fingers grazing my skin so lightly that it tickles and sends more shivers down my spine, making my flesh cover itself in goosebumps. 

"I love you in ways that I shouldn't Nic." he says , his mouth coming to mine as my breath hitches and he kisses me softly. 

I've always loved Daniel. Daniel has always loved me. But I know what he's telling me isn't the love that we've shared as just in-laws.

"I want to keep making beautiful children with you Nic" he says and kisses my mouth softly again, his hands on my hips leading me back to the bed. 

"Sometimes I wish it were just you and me" he whispers. "That he was just ours" he says, as I can feel the guilt in his voice and see it in his eyes when he pulls back and then gently pushes me onto the bed, laying me down slowly. 

"I know it's wrong to feel that way..." he says shaking his head. "But....I think i'm in love with you Nic..." he shakes his head again. 

"no, I know I am." he says quietly and my heart beats triple time and my legs part slowly as he settles between them, his hard cock, pushing, then sliding into me as my breath hitches once again and he exhales shakily. 

"No more condoms.." he says shaking his head. 

"I need you to have my baby inside of you" he says.

We'd been using condoms during my ovulation days, so we could keep this going longer, needing more of each other, giving something to each other that Claudia just wouldnt understand. 

I nod, and Daniel moves slowly, the speed making the pleasure more significant as we both gasped or groaned at the slowness. Feeling evert part of each other, falling into each other on another level. 

As he moved at this pace, his cock sliding in and out of my already cum soaked pussy, I felt like I could cry. I turned my head and pulled him to me, his head on the side of mine as he breathed quietly and rocked into me. I clasped my hands to his back and let the few tears building , slip down my cheeks. 

"I love you" he whispered, breath heavy and turned and kissed the side of my face, then lifted his face higher, stilling inside of me. 

"Why are you crying?" he asked, his brows pinching. 

I smiled and shook my head. "Hormones....keep going." 

Daniel Paxton

I kept my eyes on hers, holding her head, cradling it as I braced myself on my elbows, while making love to her slowly. 

I watched as a few more tears fell, then a few more as she kept her eyes on mine regardless. 

"i love you" I whispered quietly, because it was true. 

I wasn't supposed to love her like this, but I did. 

i knew she wouldn't say it back, possibly her quilt eating at her more than mine was at me currently. But I didn't care, I just needed her to know. 

"i love you Nic" i told her, kissing her wet cheeks one by one, then her trembling lips, and parting them with my tongue gently. 

I felt her fingers tighten on my back, pulling me into the kiss, pulling me into her as I kept thrusting slowly. 

Her tongue met mine , even as her tears still fell, and I'd hoped they weren't all out of guilt. And selfishly I'd hoped they were because she was in love with me too. Selfishly hoping she was crying because she hated herself as much as I did for how it felt when we were like this. Her legs tangled around me, with my cock burying itself into her lovely cunt , over and over, torturously slow. 

"I'm going to make love to you like this all night Nic..." I tell her. 

"I'm going to make love to the mother of my child..." I say and she starts to really cry. 

I hush her and kiss her, taking in her quiet sobs as move only slightly faster.

"I'm in love with you Nic" I groan. 

"And nothing can change that now."