EroticReverie

*commissioned*

Ashers POV

When I walk into the kitchen , I find my two brothers sitting there watching my father fuck Ari over the table.

A slight remnant of anger from yesterday lies inside me , from when he smacked her face during sex. I curl a fist with both hands and then relax them when I don’t see any redness on her face , other than her eyes that also have tears streaming from them.

My father slows and Ari looks up at me and she looks nervous. As if she’s not allowed to be doing this. But she is.

“I didn’t slap her face” my father says and I nod , letting him know that I can see that.

“She said she needed pain” my dad says and I watch his hands grip her hips as he pulls back and then slides back in and I watch Ari squirm and wince and then bite her lip.

“Seems she likes anal” Cade says and my eyes widen and Ari hisses as my father gives her another slow thrust.

I have to admit , that I’m a bit jealous that he’s the first of us to have her ass. I shove the jealousy down though , because her face is beautiful as she drops her mouth open and lets out a cry of pain mixed with pleasure when my father starts to go a bit faster.

I walk over and sit opposite my brothers and watch her as she takes it. She looks at me as my father fills her ass again and again.

“Does it hurt?” I ask as I tilt my head to the side.

She nods.

“You all have such…big..cocks” she moans and lets out a cry as my father groans and pulls her hips back as he thrusts into her ass.

“She can handle more than that. Fuck her harder.” I saw. My voice low, my cock growing hard , my eyes never leaving hers.

“Is that right Ariella? Can you handle more?” My father groans and she nods breathlessly as he continues to fuck her ass. 

“Fuck” West murmurs and I see him shift in his seat and reaching to adjust himself.

“You want pain Ari?” I ask her my voice low. And she nods.

“Then that’s what you’ll get. “ I say.

“We’re all going to take turns fucking your ass.” I tell her and she lets out a whimper as my father slaps her ass.

“Harder” I growl and I watch Ari as my father pounds harder, groaning and making her yelp and squeal. Her finger nails scratching against the table and her face tightens in pain as she trembles and starts to cry again.

“Fuck.” My father groans. “Your ass is fantastic” he tells her.

“God it hurts” she cries. “It hurts so much” she whines and I lick my lips watching her and adjust my own dick in my sweatpants.

I watch Cade get up and leave the room and me and my father and West give a questioning glance as to why on earth he’d give up this show of our girl. But he comes back and slides a bottle of lube across the table.

Ari moans and Reed grabs the bottle , popping the cap and adding some to where their bodies meet and I watch as his hips move slightly and he groans.

“Fuck that’s more like it” he groans closing the cap and tossing the bottle back on the table.

“Shit” Ari cries and she lowers her head and we all watch as her head bobs with the force of our father fucking her even harder now.

“Oh god” she cries and gasps and screams little curses as he thrusts his cock into her ass with enough power to keep the table rocking each time.

I watch as her palms try to gain purchase on the table to push herself up, but his next thrust only knocks her forward again.

I watch his hand slide up her back to her hair as he sinks into her ass and then pulls her hair and bring her up, letting her prop herself up on her hands, her back arched as he continues to fuck her.

“You are so sexy sweetheart” he groans.

Ari moans. “You’re such a hot little thing” he tells her.

“You’re more than we could’ve imagined sweet girl”he groans and Ari moans.

“Tell me I’m a whore” she whines. And I watch my fathers eyes widen slightly and he looks to me and I nod.

“You’re a whore Ari, our whore” he says and she cries out.

“Hurt me” she cries. “Please”

My father groans and starts to go harder again and she yelps. We watch as her tits bounce in her tank top. West reaches over and yanks it down. I groan at the view of her hot pierced tits.

“Show them those pretty tits” Reed groans and Ari gasps and groans when he delivers a more punishing thrust.

I wonder just how sore her ass would be after this. If she could really handle each of us partaking in fucking her ass today. I thought about how much fun I was going to have, not only fucking her ass, and watching the others do so, but how much I was going to love holding her after. How much I loved taking care of her.

I didn’t like her being hurt or overused. But I knew pain wasn’t the same to her as it was to me. I understood that she trusted us by giving us the power and permission to hurt her. As much of a whore that she wished to be, I would never see her as one. She was a fucking gift. Not just to me. But to all of us. We’d been broken when her mother died. And while it wasn’t the most conventional healing. The second she came to live with us, the very second she came into our lives. We knew she was going to repair us. It was a bit messed up considering our father screwed her mother and married her. But. For some reason, it didn’t matter. Ariella was a fucking treasure. Who was currently in tears and begging for more in front of us all. I understood that maybe she needed a different pain that the one cause by losing both of her parents. Maybe this type of pain helped her forget the rest of it. It broke my heart a bit to think that might be why she craved it. But if she wanted to forget everything for awhile, we’d let her. I’d give her this, not the face slapping but whatever else she needed. I’d give her. Whether I wanted to or not.

“Reed!” She cries and I watch her face as my father sweats behind her, fucking her still, slamming hard into her and I can only imagine what it must be like for her to take any of us inside of her pussy let alone her tight ass.

She took it well though, and it was undoubtedly hot as fuck to watch, even with her tears.

I fucking loved her. So god damn much.

“You’re so deep in my ass” she whines as he held himself there and I watched as he grunted and his hips jerked and his chin lifted as he came inside her ass

“Reed” she moans my fathers name as he finishes inside her and I watch as they both breathe heavily and I watch Ari bite her lip and give a slight smile through the tear stained cheeks of hers.

“Thank you sweetheart” my father says leaning over and kissing her back.

“Mmmmm” she moans “thank you” she says turning her head and Reed leans further and kisses her still holding her hips.

“Could use some of that every morning” he says and she smiles and giggles and then whimpers slightly and moans when he slides out.

Westlan is standing and pulls down his sleep shorts and exposes himself to her.

“Give her a second” Cade says.

“No” West says and I watch Aris eyes light up as my brother moves behind her.

West grabs the lube. Adds it to her ass and his cock and then is inside her. No working it in. Just filling her again.

He goes hard immediately and Ari lets out a scream as my father walks to the bathroom.

“Oh west” she moans with a whimper.

“You’re such a little whore Ari” he groans and she moans and nods.

“Yesss” she hisses and winces with his violent thrusts and deep moans come from her between lost gasping breaths and little cries.

“We’re gonna stretch this tight ass smurf baby” he says and I almost chuckle at the way he still calls her that even while fucking her.

“You’re such a fucking whore” he says again and she moans.

“Say it Ari” he groans.

“I’m - a - fuck-ing - wh-whore” she says between cries and West’s thrusts. None of us thought that , but it was hot to hear in the moment.

“You got four cocks obsessed with you little whore” he groans.

“You like taking all our cocks?” He groans and she nods and I lick my lips as I watch her as he groans.

“Look at me whore” he groans and she lifts up as he slows his thrusts and turns her head over her shoulder.

“Tell me how much you love being a little whore Ari” he says through gritted teeth.

“I love it so much. I love getting my holes fucked by everyone in this house” she says and I let out a groan that everyone notices. And all eyes come to me.

“I love being your whore” she moans looking at me.

“I said look at ME” West groans. “I’m the one fucking you smurf baby” he says and she turns we head again and he gives her a nice hard thrust and she yelps.

My father returns to the room and take a seat , each of us sitting on a side of the table, him across from West and Ari.

“Your ass is so damn tight baby, god I could fuck this ass all day” West groans and Ari moan and he reaches around her grabbing her tits.

“Hot fucking slut” he groans.

“Beg me to fuck this Ass Ari” he groans.

“Fuck it” she moans. “Please. Fuck my ass Westlan”she moans and he groans loudly and fucks get harder.

“Please” she cries. “Oh. Fuuuuck” she squeals.

“Harder. Fuck me harder” she whimpers and her jaw drops and it seems like West has fucked the air out of her lungs as her moaning stops and she just stays silent for a long moment as he drills into her. The sound of his hips smacking against her.

She finally finds her breath and screams as West grunts and releases his hand from her tits to grab her waist and pound into her. She screams loudly and god she’s fucking gorgeous. My cock throbbing for her. Needing her ass. Wanting to feel her on my dick.

“Take it Ari” he groans. “You wanna be a whore? Then take this fucking cock” he grunts and fucks her violently and I almost jump up to push him off her when she almost collapses and falls forward crying. I quickly remind myself that she enjoys this. And settle back in my seat.

I look over and see Cades arm moving , jerking himself off under the table , watching Ari get fucked.

“You wanna take Cades cock?” West groans.

She nods.

“Then Ashers?” He asks and she nods with a moan.

“I think we’re gonna have to use you all day Ari” West grunts.

“Take turns fucking this ass. That pussy. That pretty mouth. Those hot fucking tits” he groans.

“Yes!” She cries as he groans.

“Pump all your holes full of our cum” West grunts and we all let out a slight groan. Surely all of us knowing how hot it would be to have her leaking cum from her ass and pussy. Cum from each of us buried inside her.

West finishes inside of her a few moments later , a loud groan filling the house as he fills her ass with more cum and then Cade is up out of his chair and she pants , laying over the table whimpering after West slides out and slaps her ass and then walks around the table , leans down as he strokes her hair from her face and kisses her.

“Love you smurf baby” he whispers quietly and she smiles.

“Love you too” she says trembling and kissing him back.

It doesn’t bother me because even though her eyes look at all of us with some kind of awe and love. The look she gives me. Is much more. I’m not afraid of her loving us all. I know she’s ultimately mine. The rest of them know it and her too.

West leaves for the bathroom and Cade rubs her ass.

“You good ?” He asks and she lifts up nodding her head.

Cade was cautious like me when it came to Ari. And I loved it. Knowing I wasn’t the only one concerned we were overwhelming her or hurting her. I knew West and my dad cared. But Cade and I had a different mind than them when it came to Ari.

Sure I’d fucked girls without regard before, going hard and hurting them when they wanted it. But I never worried about how much I was hurting them. But Ari was different. She was taking on four men. And while she had a seemingly insatiable appetite for sex, I still worried we were too much for her.

I watched Cade stroke her back and lean over and trail a sting of kisses up her spine and Ari moaned. Shiver and trembling.

“I’m going to fuck you slow” he says and Ari moans.

“Fuck me however you want” she says and my nostrils flare as I inhale hearing her say that. I love how much she wants to please us.

Cade kisses her and then stands and carefully and slowly pushes into her. I watch her face change with each inch he pushes inside of her. I see the look of bliss when he fills her entirely.

Cade curses under his breath , and adds a bit more lube and then fucks her slowly.

I’m not sure how I plan on fucking her ass, but watching her take it like this. Taking it slow, teasing her deeper desire for a hard fucking, is even hotter than watching her get completely nailed by my father or West

“You’re not a whore Ari” Cade groans quietly.

“Cade” Ari whimpers and I can see the look on her face. She goes to a new place. Not the “whore” mindset she put herself in. It’s a place where she’s less comfortable. A place that she finds hard to share with us.

“You are not a whore” he whispers.

Ari cries quietly tears streaming down her face and me and my father watch and West comes back out to sit with us.

“You are so special Ari” he says and I feel a lump in my throat. Because it’s true. She’s the most special person I’ve ever had in my life. And now and again she needs to be forced into this space, where she’s reminded of what is true. We let her escape to distracting place of pain and dirty rough sex, but she needs to know she’s more than that to us.

“I love you Ari” Cade groans and looks down at himself entering her and pulling out and entering again.

“I love you too” she croaks and I my throat tightens hearing her voice that vulnerable

“You are so amazing Ari” he says and she moans and whimpers. And somehow the pain of her having to hear him affirm those words, is worse than the physical pain of the roughness she was just given.

“Reach between your legs and rub your clit for me Ari” Cade says and she whimpers and reaches between her legs.

“I want you to cum with me” he says giving her gentle thrusts and I watch as Ari closes her eyes. Biting her lip as she rubs her clit.

“You are so perfect”Cade groans and I watch her gasp and he grabs her hips gently and keeps thrusting slowly.

“You’re so good for us in every way. You make us so fucking happy Ari” he says and she cries.

“Cade” she whimpers.

“Shhhh” he soothes her.

“It’s okay baby” he says and we all watch as he makes love to her.

He doesn’t let her have that safe place. Doesn’t let her hide behind the ass spanking and rough fucking.

“Cade” she cries and he groans.

I honestly had never thought about making love with a woman while in her ass. For some reason, I’d associated making love with being inside a woman’s pussy. But Cade was doing it and I know West and Reed felt the charge between the two of them. And I had to admit, I was a bit worried. Could she fall in love with the rest of them? Would the look in her eyes she had for me going to also be starting to show when she looked at the others ? I was jealous. No denying it. But I also was thankful that Cade was showing her something deeper. Giving her more than just a fuck.

I watched as she came with him, those tears still falling as she came and my chest tightened , my heart squeezing as he groaned his love for her as he came inside of her.

The other three of us sat silently. Cade had turned the mood, theres was now nothing dirty about us watching her with Cade. Because what we’d just witnessed was not dirty at all. Not even close.

Ari sniffled as Cade lifted her gently and made her turn around.

He cupped her face in his hands and tilted her chin up. I swallowed a lump in my throat and was thankful that I couldn’t see her face or her eyes, that I couldn’t see how she was looking at him. Because I wasn’t ready to share that look with anyone else.

“I love you” Cade said and she nodded.

“I love you too” her voice was quiet and he kisses each of her cheeks and then her mouth and her hands lifted to hang onto his forearms as the kissed slowly as if the rest of us weren’t even here. I hated it. I envied anyone else getting a moment like this with her.

I watched her arms wrap around Cades neck slowly and he lifted her up.

“Let me take you to my room” he whispered to her.

“I want you to myself today” he says and then looks at me. And I respected his silent request for permission and then Ari turned her head.

“We can after Asher-“ she says

And I shake my head. “It’s okay. You can go.” I force a smile.

Because I wanted her to have love. As much as she could get. I wanted her to have time with Cade if that’s what she wanted.

“Are you sure?” She asked. Her eyes searching mine.

I didn’t have to force the smile that came next. Because I saw the worry in her eyes, the promise that if I’d said no. Or asked her not to, for whatever reason. She’d tell Cade no. So I nod.

She gives a little smile and Cade gives me a nod.

“I’ll take care of her” he says and I inhale. It was like he understood that I thought I was the only one who could. I nodded again and watched them leave and Cade carry her away and upstairs.

There was silence in the room and I didn’t look up to West or my dad.

“She’s in love with you” my father said and I lifted my hand and shook my head.

“Dont” I said calmly. “I know she is. I want her to be as happy as she can be. If she falls in love with him too , it’s fine” I say. And I know neither of them believe me by the sideways glances they give each other and I sigh.

“I’m serious. Of course I’d be jealous. Any of us would be.” I say and they nod.

“I was when I realized she’d chosen you” West says.

“She chose all of us” I say.

West rolls his eyes. “You know what I mean. She fucking loves all of us. Yes. But she’s crazy IN love with you. Her smile is different when it’s directed at you. Her voice changes the slightest bit when she speaks to you. Her eyes , fuck. Her eyes when she looks at you. Even the very first time she looked at you. She looked at you differently than us. We didn’t stand a fucking chance man” West says and I sigh.

“It’s true. And you know what? The girl would do anything you told her to. If you didn’t want her with us. She’d do it. She’d give you herself entirely. Because she wants you to be happy too Asher. Why do you think she’s not fighting you on the slapping? She doesn’t want to upset you “he says and I groan and rub a hand over my face.

“I….I just. Fuck.” I say.

“Yeah. We know.” West says.

“We all fell in love with her.” West says and I look at him and then to my dad and he nods.

“But she only fell In love with ONE of us” my dad says.

“Yeah. And she chose the most miserable one” West says joking with a small smirk and I kick him under the table and he laughs.

“Her love for you will always be the greatest. I can tell. And maybe she will find herself in love with Cade or another of us. But it doesn’t change what’s between you too. “My father says and I sigh.

We hear he shower start to run and I sigh.

“Yeah. Well. I’m gonna need to get out of the house today” I say standing up.

“Want me to come with?” West asks and I shake my head.

“Nah. I’m good. Just want to take some time on my own” and he nods.

“Later” I say.

“Later” they reply