EroticReverie

Duncan Clarke Devis

Caroline Ophelia Deamonne was  a cock tease without even ever trying. I loved watching her when the group was together, how wide her eyes got when she was scared, the way she'd look away in certain parts of movies , the way she chewed the ends of her hair sometimes when she was nervous or frightened.  I also loved watching her squirm, just like Simone, I knew that being scared made her horny. It made all of them horny. But watching Ophelia get turned on, thinking she was always hiding it so well. 

It was messy to fuck around with an ex's friend, but Ophelia was always the one I had my eye on to begin with, she was cute, and she was sexy as fuck because she was so cute. I'd originally thought she was too innocent for me, so I'd went for Simone, who was probably the most outgoing and the least innocent of any of them.  I knew I wasn't going to be able to stay away from Ophelia tonight, the second I saw her hesitate at the clearing when we got to the house. I knew she was terrified, which meant she was also turned on.  Being scared didn't turn me on, because I rarely got that scared anyways, but seeing girls scared. Fuck yeah. That shit thrilled me.  Seeing Ophelia scared though, was like watching porn. I could jerk off to just a picture of her wide eyes, or her parted mouth when she gasps. 

I'd rubbed my dick through my pants listening to her as she had come down those stairs, as she'd started to search the room for me in the dark, she sounded so fucking cute, so fucking scared that I'd nearly cum in my fucking pants. 

The footsteps above us were coming closer towards to the stairs to the basement and I could hear the voices of Corbin and my brother Preston and Eve. 

"Ophelia?" Eve's voice called. 

"Down here" she called back to her friend as I finally helped her pull up her panties and jeans, stealing kisses of  her neck still as our friends moved towards the door. 

"Is Duncan with you?" Eve calls.

"Yeah" I call back casually.

"find anything down there?" my brother Preston asks. 

"I don't think so" I say and then grab Ophelias face and back her into the wall again and she gasps against my mouth and I push my tongue into her mouth.

"Just your little pussy huh?" I whisper to her. She whimpers and I grin against her mouth, my hands going up her shirt, and grab her breasts.

The stairs creak as one of them starts to come down the steps and Ophelia squirms, and I pull down her bra and grab her bare tits and I groan softly into her mouth.

"you feel good in my hands" I whisper and pinch her nipples and then quickly remove my hands from her top and turn and wave my flash light around pretending to inspect the basement. 

I see my brother come down with his flashlight and he walks over to me as the others seem to move about deciding not to explore the basement. 

He shines a flashlight at my face and I just smile. 

"Find anything upstairs?" I ask and he shines his flashlight to Ophelia, right on her face and I look and she winces from the light and he lowers it just slightly and I smirk, because pretty little Caroline Ophelia Deamonne, looks guilty as fuck as her eyes dart away nervously.

"yeahhhhh." my brother says skeptically. 

He shines his light back at me and I shrug and he sighs. 

I wasn't the only one who had it bad for Ophelia. My brother had a thing for her too, so did our friend Corbin. She was just too sweet though, we were scared to touch her. To ruin her, to taint her. But I'd had it on my mind ever since we planned this overnight bullshit. I was going to get her alone, get her all hot and bothered and make her bad just like the rest of us. 

"You better hope Simone doesn't catch you" my brother says to me and I wave him off and Ophelia takes an adorable shocked inhale of breath, truly baffled as to how my brother would know I was down here making out with her. 

"we weren't doing anything" Ophelia says and I chuckle. 

"If nothing is fingering you and making you cum, sure" I say and she gasps. 

"Jesus" Preston says and I laugh.

"What, it's fine, nobody is gonna find out." I say and Ophelia I can tell is glaring at me. 

"You fucking asshole" she hisses. 

I turn my flash light to her. 

"He's my twin brother Ophelia...he knew the second he saw me we were messing around down here...there's no lying to a twin." I tell her and she crosses her arms. 

"I like you better scared than pissed." I tell her and raise my hand to brush my knuckles over her cheek and she slaps my hand away and I laugh. 

"So brave" I taunt her and she scowls.

"Shut up" she says. 

I chuckle and turn and grab her neck and push her gently until her back is against my brothers chest. 

She gasps, and turns her head and I grab her jaw and turn it back to me.

"You should have heard her Preston....she was so scared.....we like them scared...don't we?" I ask him as I look at her as she just looks at me and I watch her jerk slightly as my brother places a hand on her waist. 

I can hear the audible hard swallow that comes from her as I lean in and brush my lips over hers. 

"Ever had two guys touch you at the same time Ophelia?" I ask and she inhales sharply and shakes her head. 

"Do you want two guys to touch you at the same time?" my brother asks and she shivers. 

"answer him Ophelia" I say gently and let my hand slip up her shirt over her stomach. 

"I don't know" she whispers and shivers when I graze my fingertips lightly down her side then back up and lift her shirt slowly. 

"Well how about we test it out and see..." I say and she breathes shakily and I push her shirt up over her breasts and then pull down the cups of her bra again.

I shine my flashlight on her chest and I smile. 

"How bout we test it out by each of us sucking one of these adorable little nipples Ophelia" I say and she whimpers as I lift my hand to one and pinch it softly. 

"Can we do that Ophelia? Can you be brave for us and let us taste your nipples?" I ask her and she trembles. 

"yes" she answers and I groan and so does Preston. 

"good girl." I say and turn her slightly, and me and Preston both place a hand on her body, mine on her stomach, his going right up beneath her breast and tugging down her bra on his side a bit more as we both start to tongue her hard nipples. 

She gasps and then moans, and I flick my tongue and Preston rolls his around his claimed nipple. 

I groan and we both suck on her nipples, quiet sucking noises made as they pop from our mouth before we claim them again and she moans. 

"do you like two guys touching you?" my brother asks her. 

"yes" she whimpers. 

"you want more Ophelia?" I ask as I stop sucking and slip my hand back and forth along the her jeans. 

"yes" she answers and I groan. 

"How about two guys fucking you Ophelia?" I ask and she tenses slightly. 

"Would you let two guys fuck you?" I ask and she moans. 

"m-maybe" she says and I groan. 

"Cause we'd really like to fuck you" I tell her and my brother groans.

"I'd really really  , like to fuck you" he says and she moans and we both suck her nipples hard again making her squeak. 

"I love sucking your tits and touching your body while they're all up stairs and have no idea what a bad little girl you're being for us" I tell her and she whimpers. 

"do you like being a bad girl Ophelia?" I groan and she nods. 

"So fucking adorable" I groan and lick over her nipple and stand grabbing her hair and she yelps as I yank it back and lick up her neck and take her mouth and she moans into it as Preston grabs both her tits, and tends to her nipples each one by one as I hold her face and claim her mouth. 

Laughter comes from upstairs and more footsteps again. 

"Basement" I hear Corbin and Eve say, assuming someone asked where we were.

"Playtime is over" I whisper against her lips. 

"Don't look so guilty when we go upstairs." I tell her and she gasps and Preston groan and bites one of her nipples and she squeaks. He chuckles and stands. I lift her bra back up and pull her shirt down for her. 

I grab her chin and lick my tongue over her sexy mouth. 

"We're going to do bad things to you tonight Ophelia" I tell her and she gasps. 

I grin, and kiss her and grab her hand and guide her in the dark and Preston follows behind us, keeping Ophelia between us both as we return upstairs with the rest of our friends.