EroticReverie

Preston

Her fear was so incredibly sexy.  The way she struggled against us, fighting us. The quiver of her voice before we put the tape over her mouth.

I was definitely the “softer” of me and my brother. But that didn’t mean I didn’t get off on some of the same shit. Caroline was the sweetest fucking girl and I craved her more than anything and now that she was ours. Now that I knew she was all in. Not denying that she was ours in front of our friends. 

I want to play with her.  I didn’t want her to have panic attacks though.  Which was why I gave Duncan a signal as we dragged her through the woods.  I agreed to his game only if I got to call it before it got too far.  

He laughed not at her. But at me when I gave the signal so early in the “game”. 

He might not care if Caroline hated him. But I did. She was too sweet to torture to the point of making her lose her god damned mind.  Although the fact that we could , that she was so easily terrified , made me hard. 

Seeing her stripped naked as Duncan adjust the ropes on the trees and her not knowing just what she’s in for has my blood pumping furiously to my cock and I reach out to her as she shivers and I lift her chin and kiss her mouth. 

She’s still scared , the adrenaline and fear still coursing through her even though she obviously knows it’s us. It’s lovely. 

“Shhh” I hush her quietly , gently removing the tape and then put my hands on her , feeling all over her naked body. A virgin. A god damn virgin and here she was letting two guys drag her out here and strip her down , and not even asking any questions. 

“I want to taste every inch of you Caroline” I say as my hands slip over her back and over her ass and then he hips and her sides. 

“Your skin is so fucking soft” I whisper and she trembles and I palm her tits, her hard nipples pressing into my hands and I rub her breasts gently and she lets out a little sound of pleasure. 

“If you hate being scared , why do you get so wet?” I ask and she lets out a breath of relief when I pinch her nipples as if the tight skin was aching to be pulled taught. 

“I don’t know” she says almost too quiet to hear. I can tell she’s confused by her reaction to fear. 

“Bring her here” Duncan says and I look over her shoulder as she turns her head and I grab her waist and turn her. 

“Shoes off.” Duncan says. 

“I want you bare. Head to fucking toe.” He says and she stops in her tracks and she looks at the rope. 

“Are those….” She pauses. 

There’s two extensions of rope fashioned like a noose at each end draped over a thick branch from above. 

“For your wrists baby” I assure her.  And I swear I hear her swallow hard in relief. Does she really think we’d put a noose around her neck for play? Well.  Maybe we would. Duncan definitely would.

He grabs her and she lets out a tiny yelp at the force he uses as he brings her to the spot below the branch. I watch as he takes each of her arms and he guessed her height perfectly. Because once both wrists are secure , the little nooses pulled to tighten around her wrists and then secured again. Her heels are off the ground just the slightest bit as she stands there naked.  She looks so fucking good.  If she wasn’t a virgin I’d walk right over and fuck her senseless. Just like that. Tied up and unable to stop me from pounding into her with enough force that I’d have her screaming in these woods. 

A virgin. Tied up. With no questions asked.  Jesus she was going to make our lives so fucking sweet.  

She already trusted us enough to let us restrain her.  To strip her naked in the woods after scaring her and attacking her making her think we were two crazy fucks about to drag her away and do god knows what to her. 

I watch Duncan stand right in front of her. His mask already off and she looks at him. Her tits are even more perky with her arms raised and her hard nipples are so fucking pointed and tight and her ribs just slightly show as she pants and her breath shakes. 

“What are you going to do?” She asks him and I see my brothers cute smirk. 

“Whatever I want Ophelia.” He says and steps closer. 

“Because you’re mine.  And you’re tied up from a fucking tree in the woods where nobody can hear you scream. You can’t run.” He says. 

“So again. What I want” he says and I see her squirm and her thighs press together. She was turned on by his threat.  Of his assertion and her own helplessness. 

“Maybe I’ll do nothing. Maybe I’ll leave you here , you and your virgin pussy.” He says reaching down to her cunt and grabbing it. She gasps and a tiny whimper comes from her lips. 

“Let one of the rapists find you…let them have you…break you in for me” he says and I cringe at the idea of anyone else having her. Even if I understand his angle, instilling more what of scenarios in her head to scare her. 

“Let them fuck this” he says and I watch her body react and I know his finger is inside of her because she inhales harshly and then lets out a pleasure moan on her exhale. 

“Let them put this pussy to good use” he says and she moans. Squirming and her feet trying to part to spread her legs until she’s on her top toes. 

“Let them make you bleed all over their fat dirty rapist cocks” he says and I hate that my dick twitches at the thought of her pussy bleeding when she’s broken into. I wanted it for myself. I knew there was a chance she wouldn’t bleed at all. But the idea of having that proof of her innocence all over my dick was hard to ignore. I bent down grabbing the dagger I’d brought with means  stepped forward to join them and her eyes moved to me as I walked behind her.  

“You’re so naughty for being such a good girl” Duncan says.  

“I’ve never met a virgin who was also such a little slut” he groans as his finger pumps in and out of her pussy and she moans.  I run my hand up her back and down and then run the blunt side of the blade across her skin and she gasps and pulls at the rope binding her and whimpers. 

“Shhhhh” I hush her and she shivers. 

“Your pussy is so wet Ophelia” he says and all of us can hear it.  The wet sound of her sex being penetrated and soaking his finger. 

“I waited so long to know how wet you’d get for me” he says to her and she moans as keep gliding the blade over her back and down to her ass.

“You’re going to cum for me Ophelia” he says and I listened to her groan and I know he’s slid a second finger as she hisses. 

“You’re going to cum for me and for Preston.” He says. 

My cock throbbed in my pants and I wanted to take it out and give it to her. Knowing this girl needed me inside of her. I think about her sweet voice pleading with me to fuck her before Duncan walked in and Simone saw me and Caroline on the floor. 

Moving behind her with me I move to the front of her and look at her.  I’ve never seen anything so fucking amazing. Her body was fucking incredible and her tits, I was obsessed with them and could easily suck them for hours  until her nipples were tender and raw. 

“Tell me what you want Caroline” I ask and trace the back of the blade down between her breasts and to her navel slowly. 

“I want to cum” she says quietly and I can’t help the grin that comes across my face. 

“How.  How do you want to cum” I ask her and drag the dagger back up and let the back of the blade push against her nipple and over it as she hisses.  

“I bet you could cum just like this” Duncan says.  And I look to him and he too is tracing curves and the soft hills and valleys of her skin with his own blade. 

“What if we stabbed you Ophelia?” He asks and the question even surprises me and Ophelia trembles. 

“What if we…just” I watch as he lifts his hand around and takes the point of his dagger and lifts it to her breast over her heart.  

“Accidentally…” he whispers his other arm coming around her torso. 

“Shoved this into your pretty little chest” he says and she inhaled with a gasp as I watch him apply the slightest bit more pressure. 

“What If this is all just a plan…pretending to want you….to get you out here….so we can use your virgin body as a sacrifice.” He says in a few voice that brings a new fear to her eyes and she looks at me for reassurance. I give it to her with a slight shake of my head. 

Duncan was twisted. Surely. I knew that. But I wasn’t really into psychological mind games that made her think even for a second that she was here to serve as sacrifice. I had seen the look on her face when he promised Simone she would use her and her little brother as one.  

Even talk over the darker crafts scared Caroline.  I found it cute. Duncan found it as a weapon to use against her to get himself off. 

“I’m going to put this right here…” he shows her the handle of the dagger.  It was nothing but a cheap thing with a fake leather braided around the handle. 

“This…is going to fuck your little pussy Ophelia” he says and handles the blade and lifts the end of the grip to her mouth. 

“But first you’re going to suck it like it’s my cock” he groans into her ear and I reach down and let my hand touch her between her thighs. Stroking her skin there as she opens her mouth to him and wraps her mouth around the handle and I feel my cock strain against my zipper as I watch her sexy lips wrap around it and my fingers glide up her inner thighs to her wet pussy.  

She moans as I rub her clit and Duncan groans and whispers in her ear. 

“You’re going to make me so happy Ophelia. You’re such a good little girl” he says and she whimpers and I rub her clit a bit faster with the slightest bit more pressure. 

“You’re our little virgin whore Ophelia”  he whispers. 

“I know you want this pussy fucked Ophelia” he says as he takes the knife from her mouth and reaches down behind her. 

“But I’m not ready just yet to take your innocence.  But I am ready to treat you like the whore you want to be” he says and I keep rubbing her clit and she gasps and I know he has the handle at her cunt and he whispers again into her ear. 

“Take a deep breath Ophelia, and be brave”