EroticReverie

Lily

I wasn’t sure how long this would last. Me and my sister.  Me and her boyfriend. The four of us sharing and watching each other with one another. But I knew that this summer would be one I would remember for the rest of my life. 

Nothing about this get wrong. I know it probably should. But it didn’t. I was sure that it would get out too. What happened at that party last week.  The way we fucked all those guys and each other. But it was what it was. And I wasn’t giving it up. Because there was nothing inherently dangerous about two sisters being with each other sexually. Other than being taboo, we couldn’t get each other pregnant. It was safe and it was so much fucking fun and so erotic that I knew I wouldn’t be the only one that held this summer as one of their best memories already. 

“Oh god Lily” Emily moans and her head goes back as she stands there , her panties off now, my tongue licking between her pussy lips and against her clit. 

I would’ve never thought that I could enjoy going down on a female this much. I’d always appreciated other women. Even had fantasies here and there of what it would be like to be with one. But I’d have never thought my first lesbian experience would have been with my own sister. 

I loved tasting her. Loved the way I could taste her in my mouth for hours afterwards. Carrying her with me on my tongue and lips even after we were done. 

“Mmm fuck, your tongue is so fucking soft” she moans and I keep licking her clit as she looks back down at me and holds my face as I look up and her and hold my tongue out as she grinds her clit against it as she pulls my face into her. 

“My god” she groans and her hips buck slightly 

“You are so fucking hot Lily, Jesus” she whimpers and I moans and push my tongue hard against her clit. Moving it back and forth against it as she gasps and nods. 

“Yeah baby” she moans. “Just like that baby girl” she bites her lip. 

Having my sister call me baby girl, while I was taking care of her needs, had my cunt aching. My clit was throbbing each time she said it.  I loved it. Loved her feminine voice and the way it praised me as our boyfriends watched us together. Both with their cocks in hand. Stroking themselves as they watched me eat my older sisters pussy. 

Jay was so quiet. With only occasional groans at things that were said or sounds that were made. Dylan was an impatient mother fucker that kept complaining how badly he wanted to fuck us. Both of their demeanors were a turn on.  I loved how badly Dylan couldn’t control himself. And I loved how Jay just enjoyed the view. How he could patiently watch and let us enjoy one another. Knowing he’d eventually get to have me again. 

Emily is so wet and my fingers push into her. Two of them fingering her slowly as it massage her clit with my tongue and she moans loudly as she fucks my fingers and tongue. 

“You look so hot in my boyfriends clothes” she moans down at me. 

“Yeah she does” Dylan agrees. 

“It turns me on so much” she says as she gently grabs my hair and pulls my mouth from her pussy. My fingers sliding out. 

“I wanna watch you fuck him” she says and Dylan groans. 

“Take the sweats off. I wanna watch you fuck him while you wear his hoodie” she says and Dylan is already shifting. 

“Maybe we should go inside” Jay says. 

We all nod in agreement. 

Dylan slips his hands around my back and pulls me along side him into the house. His hands grabbing me the second we’re inside and then crashing his mouth to mine. 

I moan into his mouth , my arms going around his neck as he lifts me by my ass. My legs going around him. 

“Dying to get back inside you Lily” he groans against my mouth and I moan and he grins his cocky grin at me. 

“You need my cock Lily don’t you?” He asks as my sister and Jay follow. I nod and he groans. 

“He might own your pussy Lily” he whispers in my ear. “But we both know whose cock you like best” he says and I moan and then kiss him fiercely. God I hated his cock fucking attitude and at the same time it drove me wild with a lust that I didn’t care to fucking analyze. 

“Don’t worry” he whispers against my mouth. “I won’t tell your boyfriend that his girl craves my cock more than his” he says. And then sits down on the couch with me in his lap straddling him and I grind against him. He was wrong. While Dylan could fuck me harder it was only because his cock allowed it. He wasn’t small by any means. He was thick but his cock fit just right inside me. Only and inch or so too much , compared to the way I could only fit a little more than half of Jay inside with screaming bloody murder. Jay could fuck me ten times harder than he does.  But Jay is a gentle fucking giant and the way he can fill me and stretch me and the way he made me feel physically as well as mentally was so much more than Dylan could give. 

But Dylan was also right. That I did crave his cock. No matter how much I hated the cocky attitude and his toxic bullshit with my sister. The guy had something about him that indeed made my pussy a fan. Traitorous bitch. 

“God. Take these fucking pants off” he groans and I lift off his lap so we can remove his sweats and then he’s pushing down his shorts and taking off his shirt and pulling me back on his lap 

“Keep the hoodie on” Emily says to us and Dylan groans. 

“Come here you little whore” he grins and grabs his cock and I scrunch my nose and he laughs slightly. 

“Youre a whore Lily, and you know it” he says and my sister and Jay both watch from the loveseat on the side of the couch , Emily’s legs spread and Jays cock in his hand as he strokes it. 

I watch Emily grab his hand and pull it between her legs and Dylan turns my face back to him. 

“Eyes on me little Lily” he says as I lower myself onto his cock. 

It wasn’t that I was jealous. Or maybe I was. Just a little bit. It was hot watching my sister get off. Even if it was with Jay. It was only fair that we ALL shared one another. But there was a possessiveness in me for both of them. It was mainly Jay that my mind had to work on sharing. I didn’t want him to want anyone but me. It was selfish.  But it was true. I was obsessed with him now. Unable to ever stop wanting him to touch me or be near me. I was his.  I didn’t want anyone else being his. 

The slip of Dylan’s cock into my wet pussy makes the jealousy easier to swallow. 

“Fuck yes” Dylan groans and grabs my bare ass as he guides me up and down on his cock. My pussy immediately sinking all the way down. Just the right amount of pain hits my cervix as every inch of him buries itself inside of me. 

“God damn, you wet little whore” he groans and pushes my hips back and pulls them forward and I moan as my clit rocks against him and I start to grind against him. 

My eyes shift and I see Jay fingering Emily, her hand stroking his cock as they both watch. Emily smiles at me , Jay looks at me as if he’s not even touching her. As of her hand isn’t on his cock. He’s focused on me. On what I’m doing and he nods at me. 

“She looks so good when she fucks” Emily says and Jay groans and Emily strokes his faster. Working her hand at the top of his cock , her thumb passing over the head , smearing his precum all over making the tip of his cock shine. 

“She looks fucking incredible” he groans and Dylan again turns my face back to him. 

“Look at ME , you little slut” he groans and I shut him up with a kiss and he bites my lip and I groan as I move faster. Moving up and down now, letting his cock and my pussy enjoy the feeling of his cock sliding in and out of my drenched cunt. 

He groans and turns his head , to bring his mouth to my ear on the side of my face that away from my sister and Jay. 

“If you were my girl, nobody would fuck this pussy but me” he says and I whimper. 

“He’s crazy for sharing you” Dylan says and I know he’s trying to fuck with my head. It’s Dylan. He wants to be number one. He wants to win everything and make me his even though he’s my sisters fucking boyfriend. 

“If you were mine, you’d never have a chance to fuck any other cock, because I’d be inside you constantly Lily” he groans and gasp as he thrusts upward and I bounce on his cock and then he holds me down on it. 

“I’d never let another man fucking touch you.” He says. 

“Youre too fucking cute, too god damn sexy , too fucking perfect to let anyone else have” he says and I moan. 

It didn’t matter what he said. While the possessiveness was a turn on , even if I wasn’t his to possess, it made me hotter for him. But I liked that Jay enjoyed watching me with Dylan. With those other guys that night. With my sister. I liked that he could be possessive while also confident in his ability to hold me down. It was a turn on that Jay had no insecurity when it came to knowing that I was definitely his. No question about it. The guy has done something to me and made me want to do everything and anything for him. He turned me on in ways Dylan never could. 

“Fuck Lily” he groans. “How’s your little pussy so fucking good?” He says and kisses my neck as I moan and his hands slip from my ass up under his hoodie to my waist. 

“Best little cunt” he groans. 

“Fuck, I wish you were mine” he groans into my ear. 

“I’d fuck you full of my cum every day, make sure to fucking throw out your birth control and force my fucking cum to breed your sexy little pussy” he says and I clench around him making him grunt. His hands sliding up my back and pulling me to him. His hands curling over my shoulders to pull me down on him as he thrusts up into me hard again and again. 

“I’d make you a pregnant teenage slut” he says and I curse and he groans. 

“The thought of your little body carrying my baby” he groans. 

“I’d be fucking you in the hospital bed after you pushed out one, just to give you another” he says and I curse again and bite his neck and he groans and one hand falls down my back and slaps my ass. 

“You like that don’t you?” He bites my neck back and I cry in a whimper. 

“I wanna steal you, runaway and tie you down and fuck your little body till I impregnate you, send you back to him with my fucking baby inside you, teach him a lesson about sharing such a precious fucking whore” he groans and I grab his face. 

“God , shut up” I whimper and kiss him hard and he groans. 

Yes , his little fantasy was a turn on. Not something I actually wanted. But hearing his little fantasy definitely was a turn on at the same time.  The thing was. I could see the crazy cocky bastard actually doing such a thing. Just so he could “claim” me. Make me his. He didn’t care he was with Emily, he’d do it anyways. 

“Alright” Emily says. And I’m panting as she walks over and then smiles and leans down and kisses me. 

“I need some cock” she grins and I give a little laugh. 

“Jay has one” Dylan says. 

My sister rolls her eyes. 

“Yeah. He does. Thanks captain obvious. But I want my boyfriends dick” she says and he groans as I lift up and he pulls me back down. 

“I’m busy” he says and Emily rolls her eyes. 

“You’d literally fuck her all night you greedy fuck” she says and he grins at me. 

“Sure would” he says. 

“Tell her to fuck off. Tell her how much you love this cock” he says and I laugh slightly and kiss him and I push up. 

“No thanks” I say and he scowls as I push off him and move out of the way as Emily straddles him. 

“Little bitch” he mumbles and Emily smacks him. 

He smacks her back and then the two of them are choking each other out as Emily starts to ride him hard and fast. I almost laugh and just shake my head at how fucking crazy and toxic they are. 

I look at Jay who is standing now and then reaches out and grabs me by Dylan da hoodie and pulls me to him and I giggle looking up at him. I bite my lip at the hungry way he looks down at me and then grabs the hoodie and lifts it. 

“Get this fucking shit off” he says and my hands go up as he pulls it off and throws it and then is grabbing me and lifting me as I let out a little yelp and how quickly and easily he handles me. 

“No more wearing his shit” he says and the possessiveness in his tone shocks me. Was he jealous? Actually jealous?  I nod and he carries me out of the room. 

“You’re mine” he says and pushes me against a wall. Pinning me to it with his body and I nod. 

“I know I am” I say my voice soft and concerned. I reach up and touch his face. 

“I’m yours”  I tell him. 

“I think I’ve had my fill of watching you fuck him for awhile” he says. 

“Okay” I say gently and then slip my hand up the back of his head and pull his mouth to mine. 

“I’m yours” I tell him again. “I won’t fuck him again until you tell me to” I say and he groans. 

“Lily, fuck” he groans. 

“What the fuck are you doing to me little girl” he growls slightly and kisses me and I moan against his mouth. 

“I’m just being your good girl” I say and he curses. 

“Baby” he groans. 

“Fuck me “ I whisper on his lips. 

“Fuck me hard Jay, show him owns my pussy” I say and he kisses me hard. His hands grabbing my ass even harder as he lifts me higher and then takes me upstairs.